THE END OF THE WARRIOR AND THE ANGEL: PSYCHOLOGY OF AN IDENTITY IN TRANSFORMATION - Deborah Breda - ETHICA SOCIETAS-Rivista di scienze umane e sociali

The Crisis of Masculinity between Cultural Change, Psychic Integration, and Social Transformation

Abstract: The evolution of gender models as dynamic psychological, cultural, and social processes, moving beyond the conception of roles as fixed and immutable structures. Through a dialogue between Jungian analytical psychology, social psychology, and contemporary gender theories, the integration of masculine and feminine polarities is explored as a factor of balance and psychological well-being. Particular attention is given to the transformation of masculinity, the crisis of traditional models, and the possible dysfunctional outcomes when change is not symbolically elaborated. The body and aesthetics are interpreted as social texts and performative spaces of identity in becoming. Finally, an ethical reflection is proposed on the need to accompany these transformations through education to differences and a psychology of integration.

Keywords: #genderpsychology #genderidentity #masculinity #integratedmasculinity #psyche #analyticalpsychology #CarlGustavJung #Jung #AnimaAnimus #psychicshadows #performativegender #JudithButler #SandraBem #emotionalintelligence #vulnerability #bodyassocialtext #genderaesthetics #softboy #patriarchy #educationtodifferences #socialchange #ethics #DeborahBreda #EthicaSocietas #ScientificJournal #ethicasocietasjournal #scientificjournal #ethicasocietasupli

versione italiana

Introduction: Imprint and Movement

Human societies have always constructed gender frameworks as cognitive, symbolic, and behavioral maps designed to differentiate the “masculine” from the “feminine.” These models, although traditionally perceived as natural or immutable, are in fact dynamic and historically and culturally situated. Psychology has often attempted to classify these differences, at times crystallizing roles that are instead intrinsically evolutionary.

This article proposes a theoretical and reflective pathway that accompanies the transition from a rigid conception of gender roles to a psychology of identities understood as dialogical processes in continuous becoming.

Psychic Roots: Jung and the Shadow of Roles

Carl Gustav Jung interprets the persistence of gender schemas through the archetypes of Anima and Animus, which represent, respectively, the feminine principle within the male psyche and the masculine principle within the female psyche. These archetypes do not deny sexual difference but rather point to a symbolic structure of the psyche endowed with an internally complex and potentially androgynous nature.

When these dimensions are repressed by rigid social norms, they do not disappear but are relegated to the Shadow, generating psychic imbalances and partial personalities. Archetypal figures such as the “warrior” or the “mother,” when absolutized, testify to the interruption of an integrated inner dialogue.

The Turning Point: Social Psychology and the Deconstruction of Roles

Over the course of the twentieth century, social psychology and feminist movements challenged the naturalization of gender roles. The research of Sandra Bem demonstrated how the integration of masculine and feminine traits fosters psychological adjustment and behavioral flexibility.

Judith Butler introduced the notion of gender as performance, shifting attention from an alleged biological essence to socially reiterated and regulated practices. This approach enabled a radical critique of rigid norms, restoring plurality and dignity to subjective experiences.

Masculinity in Transition: From Fortress to Integrated Fragility

The traditional model of masculinity, founded on physical strength, emotional control, and authoritarian supremacy, is today profoundly challenged. This crisis arises from awareness of the psychological and relational costs of so-called toxic masculinity: a set of norms that encourage emotional repression, denial of vulnerability, and the adoption of aggressive or controlling behaviors.

The shift toward an “integrated masculinity” entails a profound rethinking of what it means to be a man, overcoming the opposition between strength and weakness. Drawing on the Jungian notion of Anima, this perspective values fragility as part of psychic strength. Emotional intelligence becomes central: fear, sadness, and insecurity are recognized as evolutionary resources.

In the absence of symbolic, educational, and psychological containment, such transformations may generate disorientation and threats to identity. In vulnerable individuals, this may translate into dysfunctional, sometimes violent behaviors, as expressions of a defensive resistance to change. This is not a direct causal link, but rather a convergence of individual, cultural, and relational factors.

The Body as Social Text: Gender Aesthetics in Transformation

The evolution of psychic schemas is reflected in aesthetic standards. The feminine bodily ideal has shifted from maternal forms to androgynous silhouettes, from hyperfemininity to slenderness, and toward the valorization of strong, athletic bodies that combine strength and grace.

In parallel, masculine aesthetics have abandoned the univocal ideal of impassive virility. From the dandy (Lord George Bryan Brummell) to metrosensual sensitivity, and up to the figure of the “soft boy,” models emerge that are founded on sensitivity, introspection, and emotional intelligence.

This aesthetic fluidity goes beyond vanity: the body as a social text becomes a site of inner dialogue between archetypes. Self-care and style take on performative value, enabling experimentation with gender identity in becoming.

The Shadowed Fruits of Change: When Disorientation Becomes Violence

Female autonomy is a fundamental achievement, but in contexts still marked by patriarchy it can activate pathological reactions in men who experience change as a threat to their identity.

The inability to symbolically elaborate this shift, combined with narcissistic fragilities and internalized power models, fosters dynamics of possession and control. In extreme forms, this leads to femicide, an expression of the darkest shadow of change, making education toward differences and a profound reworking of masculine identity urgently necessary.

Challenges and Perspectives: Anxiety, Fluidity, and New Syntheses

The contemporary era is marked by anxiety of choice and disorientation, linked to unstable gender models. Non-binary and gender-fluid identities are emerging, challenging traditional categories. Psychology is called upon to accompany these processes, fostering the exploration of the authentic self and promoting a fluid and inclusive psychic dialogue.

Conclusion: Toward an Ethics of the Integrated Psyche

The transformation of gender models is not a simple opposition between tradition and modernity, but a profound psychic and cultural reorganization. The dialogue between analytical, social, and developmental psychology shows how the integration of masculine and feminine polarities represents a higher synthesis.

Thus emerges the possibility of an ethics of the integrated psyche, in which diversity becomes a source of awareness, balance, and authentic human development.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Jung, C. G. (1958). The Anima and the Animus (discussion as part of the Jungian corpus).
Bem, S. L. (1974). The measurement of psychological androgyny. Journal of Counseling and Clinical Psychology, 42(2), 155–162.
Butler, J. (1990). Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge.
Fondazionesinapsi.it (2021). Masculine and feminine: the two archetypes and their potential. Accessed November 4, 2025.
Scuolapsicoterapia-aneb.it (2017). Call me by your name: history of identity and sexuality. Accessed November 4, 2025.
Stateofmind.it (2021). Gender dysphoria: old and new theories. Accessed November 4, 2025.
Sipsis.it (2017). “Gender”: An introductory guide. Accessed November 4, 2025.
Biography of Lord George Bryan Brummell (1778–1840), first exponent of dandy fashion. Accessed November 4, 2025.