ETHICA SOCIETAS-Rivista di scienze umane e sociali
Image default
Cristina Di Silvio Notizie Sociology and Social Sciences

The Freedom to Choose the Future: Demography, the Body and the Limits of Power

From Reproductive Freedom to Europe’s Demographic Crisis: The Difficult Balance Between Self-Determination, Motherhood and the Collective Interest

Cristina Di Silvio

Abstract: The demographic crisis facing European societies raises a question that extends beyond statistics: to what extent may a collective interest affect the most intimate individual choices? The issue emerges particularly clearly in the sphere of reproduction, where the desire to support higher birth rates may come into tension with the principle of self-determination. The Italian abortion debate of the 1970s and the subsequent framework established by Law No. 194 of 1978 reveal a question that remains relevant today concerning the relationship between personal freedom, the protection of motherhood and collective interests—a question now renewed by Europe’s demographic crisis, characterised by low fertility, the postponement of motherhood and changing family models. There is no simple causal relationship between the expansion of individual freedoms and declining birth rates. Rather, a broader political and bioethical issue emerges: a society can promote conditions favourable to parenthood without turning reproduction into an implicit obligation. Ultimately, the question concerns the limits of public power when the collective future enters the most private sphere of human existence.

Keywords: #SelfDetermination #Demography #Abortion #Motherhood #Freedom #PublicPower #BirthRates #Bioethics #CristinaDiSilvio #EthicaSocietas #EthicaSocietasReview #ScientificJournal #Humanities #SocialSciences #EthicaSocietasUPLI


versione italiana


When the Future Becomes a Political Question

In 1976, Italy was still debating in legal and political terms an issue that concerned, first and foremost, women’s bodies and lived experience. On the RAI programme A Z, un fatto come e perché, Oriana Fallaci intervened in the debate on abortion, asserting the centrality of women’s voices in a matter that directly affected their lives. Her observation concerned more than the composition and dynamics of a television programme: it raised a question that would remain central—the relationship between those who make decisions and those who must actually bear their consequences.¹

Almost half a century later, that question has acquired a broader dimension. It no longer concerns only the termination of pregnancy, but the relationship between the individual and the community at a historical moment in which the future has once again come to be perceived as uncertain. European democracies are simultaneously confronting geopolitical transformations, population ageing, declining birth rates and increasing pressure on welfare systems. Demography has inevitably become a matter of public concern. Yet this is precisely where a difficulty emerges: the collective future also depends on decisions that belong to the most private sphere of human existence. Having a child is not a demographic act. It is a personal, emotional, familial and economic choice. For this reason, declining birth rates cannot be addressed solely through the number of births.

Demography is not an individual fault

The European data are striking. In 2024, approximately 3.55 million children were born in the European Union, while the total fertility rate fell to 1.34 children per woman, the lowest level recorded since 2001. Malta recorded the lowest rate in the Union, at 1.01. In the same year, the mean age of women at the birth of their first child in the EU reached 29.9 years.²

These figures have economic and social consequences: they alter the age structure of the population, relations between generations, demand for health and care services and, in the longer term, the availability of labour. Yet these data do not automatically justify conclusions about individual choices. Low fertility may be associated with multiple factors: changing family models, higher levels of female education, women’s entry into and continued participation in the labour market, housing costs, economic insecurity, delayed parenthood and difficulties in reconciling work and care responsibilities.

Reducing all of this to the progressive assertion of individual autonomy would therefore mean conflating different phenomena. The more interesting question is not why individuals have become “too free”, but why, in certain societies, some people decide not to have children despite wanting them, or postpone parenthood until biological, economic or family circumstances become less favourable. This is where public policy encounters an essential limit: it can influence the conditions under which choices are made, but it cannot replace the choice itself.

From the protection of motherhood to demographic policy

Italian Law No. 194 of 1978 already contains, in its first article, a more complex normative framework than its title concerning the voluntary termination of pregnancy might suggest. The law simultaneously affirms the right to conscious and responsible procreation, recognises the social value of motherhood and protects human life from its beginning. It also establishes that the voluntary termination of pregnancy is not a means of birth control and assigns public services a role in preventing the circumstances that may lead to the decision to terminate a pregnancy.³

The significance of this framework lies in the fact that, at least at the normative level, it avoids a simplistic opposition between motherhood and self-determination. Protecting motherhood is not the same as imposing motherhood. This distinction remains crucial today.

A policy aimed at addressing declining birth rates can intervene in the costs of parenthood, childcare services, work–family reconciliation, housing availability and employment stability. It is quite another matter to use demographic decline as a justification for restricting the sphere of reproductive decision-making. In the first case, public authority expands people’s real opportunities. In the second, it risks transforming a collective objective into a criterion by which private choices are judged.

The paradox of freedom

The relationship between individual freedom and declining birth rates contains a paradox. Western societies have progressively removed motherhood from the logic of social destiny. Access to education, employment, contraception and more autonomous forms of organising one’s life has profoundly transformed the condition of women. At the same time, the family has changed, and having children has become increasingly detached from the biological and social expectation of producing numerous offspring.

It would, however, be misleading to transform this historical sequence into a straightforward causal relationship. Individual freedom does not, by itself, explain declining birth rates. Indeed, the opposite question may be asked: if a society wants more children to be born, how much of its public policy is actually directed towards making parenthood compatible with personal autonomy?

The distinction is fundamental. A demographic policy consistent with a free society should ask not how to persuade people to have children, but what obstacles prevent them from doing so when they wish to.

Moral conflict cannot be eliminated

Abortion remains one of the issues in which the conflict between values is most apparent. There is a genuine difference between those who attribute decisive moral value to prenatal life and those who regard a woman’s self-determination as paramount. A serious discussion cannot eliminate this disagreement through labels.

The task of institutions in a pluralistic society is not necessarily to produce a moral consensus where none exists. It is to establish rules capable of governing disagreement without automatically turning it into exclusion or coercion. The problem of freedom becomes particularly visible here: it is relatively easy to defend a choice when one considers that choice to be right. It is considerably more difficult to accept a sphere of freedom for a choice one would personally reject. Democratic pluralism is also measured by its ability to accommodate this difficulty.

The limits of power

The demographic crisis introduces a new dimension into the debate. When the state regards births as a strategic resource, the body may come to be viewed not only as the domain of individual freedom, but also as the place in which part of the collective future is produced. It is precisely at this point that particular caution is required.

A society may have an interest in higher birth rates without possessing an unlimited claim over the reproductive choices of its citizens. The point is not to deny the legitimacy of family or demographic policies. It is to distinguish between support and coercive direction, between policies that remove obstacles and policies that regard certain private choices as more consistent with the interests of the state than others.

This distinction is especially important because the consequences of demographic policy fall asymmetrically upon bodies. Pregnancy, childbirth and the termination of pregnancy are not abstract experiences: they have concrete physical, psychological, professional and social consequences. The individual who must make the decision cannot therefore be erased from the statistical representation of the population.

The future a society seeks to preserve

The demographic question should not be reduced to an opposition between pronatalists and defenders of individual autonomy. A society may seek higher birth rates while simultaneously recognising that the decision to become a parent belongs to the personal sphere. It may recognise the social value of motherhood without turning motherhood into a duty. It may support families without determining which form of family should be regarded as the only legitimate one. It may acknowledge that a stable population matters for the sustainability of social systems without transforming individuals into instruments of that sustainability.

This is the point at which the demographic question becomes a question of political freedom. The future does not consist solely in the number of people who will be born. It also consists in the conditions of freedom in which those people will live.

The future as a choice

The demographic crisis poses a difficult question for contemporary democracies: how can a collective interest be protected without turning it into a means of controlling individual lives?

There is no purely demographic answer, because fertility is not determined by a single variable. Nor is there an exclusively individualistic answer, because reproductive decisions are made within economic, social and institutional conditions.

A possible balance can be sought in the distinction between creating conditions and imposing outcomes. The state can make parenthood less costly, support motherhood, improve services, reduce inequalities and facilitate the reconciliation of work and family life. In other words, it can expand substantive freedom.

It would be quite different to use anxiety about the future as a justification for restricting the freedom of those who will have to inhabit that future. A society does not demonstrate its strength merely by ensuring its demographic continuity. It also demonstrates its strength when it is capable of pursuing collective objectives without appropriating the most intimate decisions of its citizens.

The real question, therefore, is not merely how many children will be born. It is how much freedom will remain to those who must decide whether to have them.


Notes

  1. RAI Teche, Oriana Fallaci, “Sulle donne la parola alle donne”, documentation relating to the programme A Z, un fatto come e perché, 1976.
  2. Eurostat, “EU fertility rate at 1.34 live births per woman in 2024”, 6 March 2026; Eurostat, Demography of Europe – 2026 edition, European Commission, Luxembourg, 2026.
  3. Italian Law No. 194 of 22 May 1978, Norme per la tutela sociale della maternità e sull’interruzione volontaria della gravidanza, Art. 1.

Essential bibliography

Beauchamp, T. L.; Childress, J. F., Principles of Biomedical Ethics, Oxford University Press, New York.

Berlin, I., “Two Concepts of Liberty”, in Four Essays on Liberty, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1969.

Dworkin, R., Life’s Dominion: An Argument About Abortion, Euthanasia, and Individual Freedom, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1993.

Eurostat, Demography of Europe – 2026 edition, European Commission, Luxembourg, 2026.

Jonas, H., The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1984.

Nussbaum, M. C., Creating Capabilities: The Human Development Approach, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2011.

Okin, S. M., Justice, Gender, and the Family, Basic Books, New York, 1989.

Sen, A., Development as Freedom, Alfred A. Knopf, New York, 1999.


Latest 5 contributions by the same author

Being Prepared

When Climate Change Reshapes Global Strategy

Netanyahu-Erdoğan: The Conflict Is No Longer Merely Verbal — Syria at the Heart of the New Middle Eastern Competition

Ceuta, When the Border Becomes a Weapon

Ceuta: Digital Mobilization and the Jihadist Threat

LATEST 5 CONTRIBUTIONS ON POLITICS

The Italian Republic’s Longest-Serving Government Faces the Test of the Economy

When Climate Change Reshapes Global Strategy

Europe: Market or Power?

Draghi in Aachen: Europe Alone Before the Test of Sovereignty

Holocaust Remembrance and Contemporary Antisemitism

LATEST 5 CONTRIBUTIONS

Oriana Fallaci, Twenty Years Later

From Gender-Based Violence to Children’s Exposure to Domestic Violence: Protecting Victims Means Recognising What Children See and Experience

Who Decides When a Woman Is Free?

International Week of Deaf People: From Accessibility to Full Citizenship

Free to Offend or Free from Offence?


Ethica Societas is a free, non-profit news publication published by a non-profit social cooperative.
Copyright Ethica Societas, Human&Social Science Review © 2026 by Ethica Societas UPLI onlus.
ISSN 2785-602X. Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0

Related posts

Gender-based Violence as a Clinical and Public Health Phenomenon: the Padova Charter 2026

Silvia Zaghi

Camera Traps That Record Data Locally, Even When Encrypted, Are Unlawful

Massimiliano Mancini

The Coalition of the Willing and a Guarded Peace: the West Between Deterrence and Disengagement

Cristina Di Silvio